My Photo

Insight Scoop

Catholic World News Top Headlines (

The Curt Jester


Poor Box

Render Unto Us

Tip Jar
Blog powered by Typepad

« Pope Benedict XVI Reaffirms That The Catholic Church Is The One, True Church; Changes The Good Friday Prayer | Main | The Elephant In The Big Tent – “Bush Sr., Dole, Bush Jr., McCain: Where’s the substantive difference?” »

Wednesday, February 06, 2008




Here's an opposing view, although, I agree with your assessments...I found it on CNN as an Op-Ed: The interesting comment was from Bill Bennett who said, basically, Reagan wasn't always Reagan...please enjoy the read!

Listening to the irrational and hysterical response of conservatives to the presidential candidacy of Sen. John McCain would be laughable if it wasn't so serious.

Roland S. Martin says some conservatives are opposed to Sen. John McCain's run to the presidency.

During a debate Tuesday on CNN's "The Situation Room," conservative radio talk show host Glenn Beck said that the Republican Party has lost its soul, and McCain is indicative of that problem. He even said that if Sen. Hillary Clinton is the nominee, he will ignore McCain and cast a ballot for her.

Now, how silly is that?

Looking at the exit polls from Super Tuesday, McCain did well in some states with conservative voters, but he continues to run strong among moderates and independents. He clearly has a lot of work to do to shore up this important constituent in the party.

Let's be clear -- conservatives don't like McCain. But with conservatives one seat away from having a majority on the Supreme Court and the next president having the power to name up to three justices, do you actually think the folks who've fought two generations to re-take the Court actually want to see three Clinton jurists?

This, folks, is bordering on the irrational.

It all revolves around this desperate desire to find the new Ronald Reagan. He is the conservative icon. However as conservative Bill Bennett told me Tuesday night during one of our breaks in Super Tuesday coverage, Ronald Reagan wasn't always Ronald Reagan. His positions on taxes and gays evolved.

Don't Miss
McCain emerges as GOP leader
Election Center 2008
Commentary: Forget Democratic 'dream' ticket
Archive: Roland S. Martin
But don't tell that to conservative radio hosts like Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity and Laura Ingraham, who have vowed to destroy McCain because he doesn't carry their water on every issue. Most issues? Yes. But they require their politicians to assume a fetal position, not to have a backbone and stand up to them when needed.

McCain is a guy who is fiercely pro-life. That's a pretty important issue for the conservatives. He is strong on the military and being a former Vietnam prisoner of war sure doesn't hurt. When Republicans got weak-kneed over the surge in Iraq, McCain stood tall and proclaimed that it will work.

The guy is a fiscal conservative who abhors the spending that has taken place during the presidency of George W. Bush and the Congress under Republican rule. Yes, he voted against the first two Bush tax cuts. But as he said, when you don't have spending limits with tax cuts, you blow up the federal deficit, and we are a weaker nation today because Republicans acted like a teenager with Mom and Dad's credit card.

What you will hear from conservatives is that he has co-sponsored legislation with several Democrats, including former Democrat-turned-independent Sen. Joe Lieberman. Of course, I crack up laughing because conservative talkers have a love affair with Lieberman yet they rip McCain apart for trying to actually accomplish something in a bipartisan manner.

What they seem to be most angry about is that McCain teamed up with Wisconsin Sen. Russ Feingold to move through a law that severely restricted the dollars in federal elections. This angered conservatives because they viewed the issue as a First Amendment cause. In fact, they really were upset about the GOP losing a major advantage over the Democrats when it came to fundraising. With that window narrowed by the law, they didn't want to see that advantage disappear. The U.S. Supreme Court struck down some parts of the law, but that still hasn't satisfied the money vultures on the right.

Lastly, there's the immigration debate.

In an effort to exercise leadership on a volatile issue, McCain chose not to be a demagogue and work out a compromise bill that would curtail the nation's unsecured borders, while figuring out a way to deal with the 12 million illegal immigrants already here. If you talk to the rabid conservative talk show hosts and their wild and angry listeners, their only option is to throw these immigrants out of the country. In former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, they have a very sympathetic ear.

But we all know the truth. That will never happen. Never.

So instead of drooling at such prospects, McCain worked with Democrats and some Republicans to offer a solution, which included making illegal immigrants learn English, pay a fine, force them to get in line for citizenship while targeting businesses that hire them.

Yet, the anger in America was too great. Whites, blacks, some Hispanics, conservatives, and even liberals couldn't stomach doing this first and not securing the borders.

Folks, McCain is a pragmatic leader trying to solve a difficult situation.

Conservatives will do anything to stop him, with some even suggesting -- especially evangelicals -- that they might run a third-party candidate.

Word to the wise: Shut up, suck it up and deal with it.

If McCain wins the nomination, he is the best option the GOP has to stopping the candidacies of Sens. Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama.

Roland S. Martin is a nationally award-winning journalist and CNN contributor. Martin is studying to receive his master's degree in Christian communications at Louisiana Baptist University, and he is the author of "Listening to the Spirit Within: 50 Perspectives on Faith." You can read more of his columns at


Conservatism is a do it yourself, take care of yourself and your own family philosophy which is informed by religious convictions that lead us toward (quiet) charity-care for the needy.

Big government is the antithesis of Conservatism. McCain is a big government savant who succeeded in limited our Freedom of Speech via McCain-Feingold (i.e. political speech, the absolute essence of our Founding national docuents).

Not so very long ago there was the insight that: "Only Nixon could go to China." Back when China was a hugely worrisome unknown seemingly (and actually) malevolent force. Nixon, a life long anti-Communist, thus was the "only" political leader with enough "creds" to go and entend peace-cooperation to that Nation in a effort to reduce their (nuclear war) threat.

UNFORTUNATELY, I think that today: "Only McCain can lose a war to Islamo-Fascism."

I agree with Rush Limbaugh regarding Hillary and Obama that they will not actually DO one thing differently from George Bush in Iraq (i.e. now that ALL of the heavy lifting decision making is done and the Iraqi's are hopefully going to make the sensible decision to survive and prosper, rather than sink back into the sewage of Islamic hatred among their lowest common denominator bretheren).

The "fact" of McCain's war hero status, would tend to give him the "creds" to actually do the ONLY stupid thing that might or could be done, that being make some sort of accommodation to the horrible demonic "religion of peace" Islamic "theory" of slavemaster government over their masses.

I personally think McCain is NOT any sort of war hero. He is much more of a Jessica Lynch character (if my memory serves, that is the girl who was riding on the back of a kitchen patrol truck when it got lost on the Iraqi roads and was hit by enemy fire, she was knocked out cold and remained unconscious for a week during which time innumerable ACTUAL brave soldiers went out and rescued her, and then our STUPID Congressional Women's Caucus put her up for our Congressional Medal of Honor - which quietly died among other stupid paperwork).

McCain was a lousey (lowest man in his class) hot head U.S. Navy pilot who got shot down over Viet Nam and injured in that crash. He was taken to the "Hanoi Hilton" prison and treated like "everyone else" (i.e. whose Dad happened to be the Chief of Naval Operations for the Pacific all during the time of McCain's captivity in Hanoi - thus when he emerged from that prison ALIVE years later, he was skinny but healed from his plane crash-injury).

There is another guy who was captured at the same time as McCain in Viet Nam (General Stockdale, similarly a young lieutenant back then) who went to the same prison for the same number of years, who also came out alive, except that he got TORTURED for every day of those many years in prison and was effectively broken and torn apart in every immaginable manner possible as is so evident "today" - he was the VP running mate of Presidential nominee Ross Perot, some years ago - that you could hardly keep from diverting your eyes when looking at his crippled-ruined body - but then his Dad was NOT the CINCPAC during the Viet Nam War, as was "the hero" McCain's.

I think McCain is "The Manchurian Candidate" of the old (1970s?) Hollywood movie fame, now come to life, in order to destroy the Republican Party and every notion of legitimacy which actual Conservatives brought to that Party, and which phony George Bush drove right out of it and into the ground, with his preview of the Huckabee "religious" "Conservative" AKA big government baffoon in office routine.


Thomistic, don't be hasty. McCain isn't my first choice...or even my fifth. His votes on embryonic stem cell research funding and gay marriage are just plain wrong. That being said, he cosponsored the partial-birth abortion ban and voted for the ban on abortions on military installations, among other pro-life votes.

I'd much rather have Romney, the Huck, or Paul as the nominee, but I'm glad we don't have Giuliani or Pataki. Am I going to be making weekend phonecalls from my cellphone for McCain? No. Am I going to be scratching out a check? No. I will vote for him, though, because the alternatives on the Dem side are horrific.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Pope Benedict XVI Homilies & Statements

Codex of Catholic Blogs

Orthodox Blogs

Blogs From People We Wish Were Catholic